This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Cart 1

Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping You are $-5,150 away from free shipping.

In stock pieces ship in 5-7 business days. Made to order pieces do not ship immediately. Check product details for production time.

Pair with
Is this a gift?
Subtotal $5,350 USD
View cart
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout.

The Rarest Gemstones Available for Jewelry!

Red diamond, Paraiba tourmaline, "Jedi" spinel, Imperial topaz, tsavorite and alexandrite are six of the rarest gemstones still available for jewelry. Plenty of stones get described as "rare," so this list breaks down what makes each of these six truly scarce, where they come from and what they cost. Prices below are typical retail ranges as of 2026 and vary widely with color, clarity, size and origin.

Loose princess cut red diamond

Photo: GIA


Red Diamond: Why Is It So Rare?

Red is the rarest diamond color: only a handful of pure red diamonds over one carat are known, and just five are known to exceed five carats. Most gemologists attribute the color to plastic deformation, where intense pressure distorts the diamond's crystal structure, though the exact cause is still debated. Most red diamonds are well under one carat and heavily included. The best-known source was the Argyle mine in Western Australia, which closed in November 2020, so very few new stones are reaching the market. A true Fancy Red diamond typically sells for hundreds of thousands of dollars per carat, and the finest stones can exceed $1 million per carat.

 

Loose cushion cut neon blue Paraiba tourmaline

Photo: GIA


Paraiba Tourmaline: What Is It and What Does It Cost?

Paraiba tourmaline, also called cuprian tourmaline, is a copper-bearing tourmaline known for its vivid, electric neon color. It is named after the Brazilian state of Paraíba, where it was discovered in the late 1980s. Brazilian material, from Paraíba and neighboring Rio Grande do Norte, is still the most prized but is now very scarce. Similar copper-bearing tourmaline was found in Nigeria and Mozambique in the early 2000s, and these African stones are more widely available and slightly more affordable. Most people picture Paraiba in its classic "Windex" blue seen above, but it also comes in green shades. Paraiba tends to be included, similar to emerald, and is sometimes clarity-enhanced with oil. While far more available and affordable than red diamond, Paraiba remains one of the rarest and most popular colored stones on the market, which shows in its pricing: a relatively eye-clean one carat Mozambique Paraiba can range from $12,000 to $40,000, and Brazilian Paraiba can cost more than double that.

 

Loose cushion cut neon pink-red Jedi spinel held on a finger

Photo: GIA


What Is "Jedi" Spinel?

"Jedi" is a trade name for spinel in an intensely bright, neon pink-red color with no brown or gray undertone, making it one of the most prized and hardest-to-find shades in the spinel family. It comes primarily from Myanmar (Burma). Jedi spinel shows an electric brightness and saturation even in the rough, along with strong red fluorescence that can be seen under UV light and even in daylight. Its color and its scarcity above two carats make it a favorite with collectors and gemstone lovers alike. Stones under one carat can occasionally be found for less than $5,000, while the most prized colors and sizes above one carat can exceed $150,000.

Loose oval cut orange-red Imperial topaz

Photo: GIA


Imperial Topaz: Why Is This Color So Rare?

Imperial topaz is the rarest and most prized color of topaz, with a warm sunset hue ranging from golden orange to reddish orange. It makes up only a tiny fraction of the gem topaz mined, and it comes almost exclusively from one region: around Ouro Preto in Minas Gerais, Brazil. Most other topaz colors, including the popular blue shades, are created by treating colorless topaz, while Imperial topaz's color occurs naturally, adding to its value and rarity. Despite its rarity, demand is modest, which keeps prices relatively stable: good quality stones often sell for around $2,000 to $5,000 per carat.

 

Loose square cushion cut green tsavorite garnet

Photo: GIA


Tsavorite: How Rare Is This Green Garnet?

Tsavorite is a rare green variety of grossular garnet and one of the rarest, and arguably most beautiful, garnets on earth. First discovered in East Africa in 1967, it was named after Tsavo National Park in Kenya, near the Tanzanian border, and introduced to the jewelry world by Tiffany & Co. in 1974. It is mined mainly in Kenya and Tanzania, with smaller finds in Madagascar. Its color ranges from a light olive green to a deep forest green, with vivid pure green being the most sought after. Good color and clarity above two carats is rare in nature, so while tsavorite has grown in popularity in recent decades, it gets expensive quickly in larger sizes. Good quality tsavorite under three carats typically ranges from $3,000 to $5,000 per carat, with prices rising sharply for exceptional stones above that size. Tsavorite is not commercially lab-grown and is increasingly chosen as an alternative to emerald, so it's a stone you won't see going away any time soon!

 

Loose oval cushion cut color-change alexandrite

Photo: GIA


Alexandrite: Why Is the Color-Change Gem So Rare?

Alexandrite is a color-changing variety of chrysoberyl that shifts from green or bluish-green in daylight to red or purplish-red under incandescent light, and it is one of the rarest gemstones used in jewelry. It was first discovered in Russia's Ural Mountains in the 1830s and named after the future Tsar Alexander II. Those deposits are now largely depleted, with smaller sources in Brazil, Sri Lanka and East Africa. Alexandrite needs both beryllium and chromium to form and change color, and those two elements rarely occur in the same rocks, which makes its formation a natural anomaly. As a result, fine alexandrite is rarer than fine diamond: good quality stones above one carat are uncommon, above two carats extremely rare, and above five carats museum-level. For a one carat stone with a strong color change, expect roughly $20,000 to $50,000, with larger stones fetching several hundred thousand dollars.


Where to Find the Rarest Gemstones

At Shahla Karimi, we're happy to help find and create the perfect piece for you, whether it's a rare Paraiba tourmaline or a classic diamond. Our team is always here to answer questions and create something special that represents you. See our bespoke process and gallery of custom projects below for inspiration!

 

OUR BESPOKE PROCESS

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published