A diamond grading report is the official record of a diamond's identity and quality: its measurements, carat weight, color, clarity, finish, fluorescence, proportions and a map of its inclusions. Diamonds are still the most popular choice for an engagement ring, but they're graded on so many specific parameters that the report can be confusing. Below, we'll break down a real GIA diamond grading report step by step, so you can understand one and know what to look out for when searching for your next stone!
What Is a Diamond Grading Report?

For this article, we'll be studying this GIA report for a natural 4.01 carat cushion diamond. The GIA (Gemological Institute of America) is the most widely recognized authority on grading natural diamonds, and reports from other grading labs look similar and show much of the same information.
With GIA, each diamond is given a report number that can be looked up online, and you'll also receive a copy of the report. Many diamonds are also laser inscribed with their report number on the girdle (the thin outer edge of the diamond), so its information can be tracked down even if the paperwork is lost.
What Do the Date, Shape and Measurements Tell You?

The first box tells us when the diamond was graded, its report number, its shape and cutting style, and its measurements. Most of these are self-explanatory, but the shape and cutting style can give good insight into how the GIA perceived the diamond. For example, this diamond was cut in an old mine style, but the GIA designated it as a Cushion Brilliant instead, likely because its facet pattern didn't fit a traditional old mine style.
The date is also important. Many of the diamonds on the market today were graded within the last 10 years. A diamond graded before that isn't necessarily a bad thing, but it's a sign to look more closely at the report and the stone to understand why it hasn't sold recently, whether it's a pre-owned diamond or something about the stone makes it "less desirable."
For elongated stones, the measurements also let you find the stone's ratio if it hasn't been shown to you already. To find the ratio, divide the length (the first measurement) by the width (the second measurement). This diamond's ratio is 10.18 ÷ 7.84 = 1.30. The ratio people prefer depends on personal taste and the shape of the stone.
What Do Carat, Color and Clarity Grades Mean?

The grading results section lists three of the most important aspects of the diamond: carat weight, color and clarity. The color and clarity are measured on scales that the GIA prints on the right side of every diamond report.
Carat weight seems self-explanatory, but it's important to keep in mind that every diamond shape carries its weight differently. Antique cutting styles like this diamond tend to carry a lot of weight in their height, so while this diamond weighs 4.01 carats, it may look smaller from the top (or "face up") than a more modern cushion of the same weight.
This diamond is graded on the GIA's D-to-Z color scale for white diamonds. Its color grade is N, which falls in the "very light" range (N to R), meaning a light yellow tint will be visible in the stone. The further down the scale, the more visible the hue.

Clarity is graded on another scale, which runs from FL (Flawless) to I3 (Included). Most engagement ring diamonds fall somewhere between VS and SI. The clarity grade goes hand in hand with the clarity characteristics plot on the report, which shows which inclusions led the GIA to grade the stone at this clarity. Not all SI2 diamonds are eye clean or visibly included, so each diamond is different. It's important to study a stone in person and look at its inclusions, as some are preferable to others.

What Are Polish, Symmetry and Fluorescence?

Polish and symmetry describe the quality of a diamond's finish, and both are graded on a scale of Excellent, Very Good, Good, Fair and Poor. On round brilliant diamonds, the GIA also gives an overall cut grade on the same scale, but for fancy shapes like this cushion, the report lists only polish and symmetry.
A diamond's polish relates to the surface quality of its facets. The GIA examines each facet to make sure it's well finished, without abrasions or other potentially visible marks. Excellent to Very Good is common in fancy shape diamonds.
A diamond's symmetry is graded on how precisely its facets are shaped and aligned. Excellent to Very Good is common in fancy shape diamonds, while grades as low as Good or Fair can be seen in antique-style cuts like this cushion, which are cut to recreate the hand-cut look of the Victorian era.
Keep in mind that gemologists grade polish and symmetry under 10x magnification, so the difference between Excellent and Very Good can be negligible to the naked eye.
Fluorescence is a glow, most often blue, that some diamonds give off under ultraviolet (UV) light, caused by trace elements in the diamond's chemical makeup. It's graded on a scale of None, Faint, Medium, Strong and Very Strong. Most fluorescence has no visible effect on a diamond in normal lighting, but in rare cases, strong or very strong fluorescence can make a diamond look hazy or milky, or show its glow in daylight. It's important to view each stone in person to check. This diamond's fluorescence is Faint.
What Do a Diamond's Proportions Mean?

Next, the GIA breaks down the proportions of the diamond. For fancy shape diamonds, this is usually the table percentage, girdle thickness, depth percentage and culet. Many companies make recommendations for what these should be for a specific diamond cut, but since they can vary so much depending on so many factors, we'll discuss just what the GIA is telling us on the report.
The table percentage compares the width of the table (the flat facet at the very top of the diamond) to the width of the diamond. In antique cut stones like this cushion, the table is traditionally smaller than in a modern cushion; this one is 54%.
The girdle is the thin outer edge around the middle of the diamond, often faceted. Its thickness is an important sign of how much weight is held there: too thick, and the diamond is keeping weight in its girdle instead of its spread; too thin, and it can risk chipping. Antique cut stones commonly have thick girdles, like this one.
The depth percentage compares the height of the diamond to its width. This diamond's depth is 5.79 mm and its width is 7.84 mm, so its depth percentage is 73.8%. A diamond that is too shallow or too deep can let light escape, limiting its sparkle. Antique cut stones like this cushion often have more depth than modern stones.
The culet is the bottommost point of the diamond. In most modern stones it's left as a point, but in antique cut styles it's cut flat. A pointed culet is one of the weakest points of a diamond if left unprotected, and a cut culet eliminates this risk. The GIA also notes the size of the culet, which can range from None and Very Small to Extremely Large. This diamond's culet is Medium.
How Do You Read a Diamond Plot?

The diamond plot, listed as clarity characteristics, is a map of where the diamond's inclusions are and what type each one is, and it's one of the most useful parts of the entire report.
In this section, the gemologist has marked the location and type of each inclusion (called clarity characteristics) on a drawing of the diamond. Internal characteristics are marked in red, and blemishes on the outside of the diamond are marked in green. There are dozens of different types of diamond inclusions, and some are preferable to others. This diamond has some of the most common: pinpoints (tiny crystals that appear as small dots), feathers (internal breaks in the stone that appear white and feathery) and crystals (minerals inside the stone, sometimes white or colorless and sometimes black and more visible). This diamond also has an indented natural, a part of the original rough diamond's surface that dips below the polished surface.
In a perfect world, you would prefer inclusions that don't reach the surface, sit near the edges of the diamond rather than the center, and sit on the pavilion of the stone (shown in the right-hand drawing). The further an inclusion is from the top of the diamond, the harder it can be to see.
The GIA has also drawn in the diamond's facet pattern on the plot, so you can see how many facets were cut and where they are. This can be helpful for finding the exact facet style you like while searching for the perfect stone.
The Diamond Reveal

Now that we've studied the entire report, let's look at the actual diamond. This is a macro image, so many aspects of the diamond are more prominent than they would be to the naked eye.
After reviewing the report, does the image match what you imagined? This is a fun way to practice and get comfortable reading and understanding a diamond report.
Diamonds with Shahla Karimi

As confusing as diamond reports can be, we're here to help you every step of the way. Have a look at our diamond collections below, including our old mine diamonds, as well as our bespoke page for inspiration on designs and diamond shapes. We're always here to help track down the perfect stone and create an unforgettable setting for it!
Leave a comment